Fairy and Snake - Steven Stahlberg Masthead - Tony Geer Astrobiology - Gerhard Hoeberth Emerald City Logo - Sue Mason
Archives Reviews Awards Web Log Subscribe Photos About Support Us

Issue #129 - May 2006

Previous Article | Next Article

Jack and the Pack

By Juliet E. McKenna

Kelley Armstrongís first two books featured Elena Michaels, the only female werewolf in this parallel version of our reality, and a woman more than able to take care of herself. Having explored Elenaís strengths and versatility, Armstrong didnít succumb to the temptation of staying with such a popular and engaging character without a story worthy of that heroine, and of her own talents as an author. Instead she broadened her scope and honed her skill writing about different characters and themes, expanding the Women of the Otherworld milieu with impressive results. As a result I feel confident Armstrong will have brought her readers back to Elena only because she has had suitable inspiration.

But I must confess to one major reservation. The cover tells us the initial impetus for this plot is Jack the Ripperís ĎFrom Hellí letter. Personally I regard the Jack the Ripper motif within supernatural fiction in much the same way as I do King Arthur and the Grail in fantasy. Itís been done. We know it too well. Itís been done well, indifferently, and frequently badly. Itís not even that good a story. Itís even been done in Star Trek and Babylon 5! I wouldnít think of touching it. So itís a measure of how much I enjoy Kelley Armstrongís books that I opened Broken with considerable interest to see how she handles this particular poisoned chalice.

The first surprise has nothing to do with Victorian serial killers. Elena is now settled, secure in her dual nature and living with her extended adopted family, her pack. That family is about to grow larger, as indeed, is Elena. Sheís pregnant, something not previously believed possible. This is an excellent move by Armstrong. In previous adventures, weíve seen Elenaís strength and intelligence. She learned from her experiences and developed into a confident, powerful opponent for any supernatural foe. Some writers deal with their increasingly dominant protagonists with corresponding escalation among their enemies, in some cases going far beyond whatís credible. Others opt for emasculation, introducing some equivalent of kryptonite. Thatís not whatís happening here; Elena is in no sense diminished by her pregnancy. But it does create new concerns for her. It also changes her relationships with her supernatural allies and with her pack mates, making this more of an ensemble piece than her previous outings. All this adds a new dimension beyond what weíve already seen.

Pregnancy also gives the reader new points of contact with Elena and with Clayton, her lover. We wonít ever be able to know what itís really like to be a werewolf, but a lot of us will become parents, if we arenít already. Even if we donít, the possibility, the questions and the apprehensions are something we can all relate to. Pregnancy notwithstanding, Elena and Clay continue to enjoy a full and active sex life. Armstrong continues to write these scenes with an astute sense of what warrants explicit detail and what is best left to the imagination. But now that their lives have moved on, this aspect of their relationship has similarly grown and changed, again giving this book and these characters new dimensions that ground the fantasy in reality.

So where does Jack the Ripper fit into this idyll? Quite simply. In return for information on a rogue werewolf preying on humans, Elena and the Pack are asked to retrieve the notorious ĎFrom Hellí letter ó long since stolen from the original files of the London police ó from the private collector in Toronto who now has it. Thereís a celebrity, nothing to do with the supernatural side of life, who wants to run DNA tests hoping to finally identify the Ripper once and for all. Given Patricia Cornwellís well-publicized crusade, thatís all nicely plausible, and again ties this fiction to our reality, as do other passing references to Ripper lore such as the recent Johnny Depp film.

Stealing the letter presents some difficulties which are solved with not too much difficulty, only the letter turns out to be a portal to a pocket dimension. Out comes a bowler-hatted Victorian thug with a penchant for knives. Dealing with him turns out to be a bit more difficult, but itís done. The next problem turns out to be what came through the portal with him, initially unnoticed. Now the challenges are coming thick, fast and complex, especially when it turns out the putative Jack isnít nearly so dealt with as they thought. Plus the Packís various supernatural allies prove to have agendas of their own.

All of which adds up to real page-turner with, thankfully, a nicely original take on the Ripper mythos as one of several motifs within the overall story rather than a dominant fixation. Armstrongís skills as a writer ring the changes through the sequence of good news, bad news and worse news. Sometimes there are clues so the reader is half a page ahead of the characters, experiencing that sinking feeling as they head into trouble. Elsewhere, reader and characters alike are blind-sided. Then again, sometimes the reader is left to play catch-up as charactersí knowledge and experiences within their own reality enable them to cope more than competently with a potentially lethal situation.

As with the other books in this series, Broken can be read as a standalone novel, and works very well as such. Then again, thereís added value for those of us who have enjoyed Armstrongís previous books. We have background to flesh out minor characters even if itís not needed for this particular story. If weíve read Haunted, we know exactly what kind of richly-deserved Hell awaits Victorian killers trapped between life and death.

The book and Elenaís pregnancy come to a conclusion together. The ending does not disappoint, bringing us back to that vital connection with these characters through aspects of life, good and bad, that even magic cannot fix and even supernaturals cannot escape. Thus we reach a natural, unforced point for a break in these adventures as Kelley Armstrong turns to stretching different writing skills in a crime series. If this proves to be the conclusion of Women of the Otherworld series, Broken is a worthy final installment. If some way down the line we revisit these characters and see how their lives have progressed, I for one will be thrilled as Iím confident that new story will be well worth reading. In the meantime, I shall re-read the books thus far and recommend them widely.

Broken - Kelley Armstrong - Orbit - mass market paperback

Previous Article | Next Article

Contents for this issue


Purchase options

For information about buying through Emerald City please click here

Broken - Kelley Armstrong - Orbit

The Book Depository

Buy this item from The Book Depository

Search The Book Depository for books by Kelley Armstrong

Previous Article | Next Article

Contents for this issue

About Emerald City | Submissions

Emerald City - copyright Cheryl Morgan - cheryl@emcit.com
Masthead Art copyright Steven Stahlberg (left) and Gerhard Hoeberth (right)
Additional artwork by Frank Wu & Sue Mason
Designed by Tony Geer
Copyright of individual articles remains with their authors
Editorial assistants: Anne K.G. Murphy & Kevin Standlee